My thinking process:

1. I was about to test https://admin.fedoraproject.org/updates/NetworkManager-0.9.3.997-0.7.fc17
2. I realized I don't know what karma to post when NM works in general, but I haven't tested the linked bug fixes
3. I know we have some karma guidelines somewhere on the wiki
4. I couldn't find the page
5. I found the page at https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Proven_tester#Feedback_procedures after some time
6. My use case doesn't seem to be mentioned anyway. But that's not important. The question is - shouldn't we link these instructions directly from the bodhi page? No one will find it otherwise.

That wiki page is proven tester specific, but the "Feedback procedures" chapter is not. I think it would be really worth the effort to create a new wiki page containing just guidelines for correct karma posting and then ask Bodhi maintainers to link that page directly from the Bodhi page. I imagine it could be displayed besides the "Add a comment" text are, named something like "Karma posting guidelines".

What do you think?

Does anyone feel like volunteering for creating this separate wiki page? I'll gladly create a ticket for Bodhi afterwards.